11-12 October 2012

Previous Next

Lot 194

1904 South Bend Surrey

  • Chassis no. MVIN178034IND

$110,000 - $140,000

219.9 cu. in. water-cooled inline four-cylinder engine, three-speed progressive manual transmission, solid front axle and live rear axle with butterfly leaf springs, Taylor sprung wheels with solid rubber tires, and two-wheel mechanical drum brakes. Wheelbase: 83 in.

• Unique, fully documented, one-off automobile

• Conserved original condition

The unequivocal bible of the old car world is the Standard Catalog of American Cars 1805–1942. In this 1,600 page tome, historians Beverly Rae Kimes and Henry Austin Clark Jr. chronicled many thousands of makes of cars, whether mass-produced, one-off, or merely considered. The two researchers set a high bar in finding a previously unknown pre-war American car; offered here is one of those examples, which is extraordinarily well-documented.

Walter E. Mack of South Bend, Indiana purchased one of the first Studebaker electric cars offered, found that it didn’t meet his expectations, and resolved to build a better car himself. He purchased an engine from the Buffalo Gasolene Motor Company. The engine had been designed by Charles Brady King but incorporated improvements by Walter Lorenzo Marr, the father of Buick’s valve-in-head design.

For a transmission, Mack used a three-speed progressive gear unit with shaft drive. The brakes are external-contracting, bronze-lined bands that act on drums on the rear wheels, and the suspension utilizes unusual butterfly-shaped leaf springs. The wheels themselves are miraculous, a sprung type patented by Horace H. Taylor in 1901. They consisted of a solid, steel-rimmed tire, wood spokes, and a hub that floated on 12 coil springs arranged radially around the center. During this period, several inventors were pursuing suspension designs of this type, either to avoid pneumatic tires or obviate the need for springs on the car itself, and Mack even formed the Indiana Wheel Company to manufacture the Taylor-patent wheels.

The South Bend Tribune reported on Mack’s test of Taylor wheels on his car during August 1904, the machine being “driven…at all kind of speeds…and all kinds of rough roads.” The Tribune again reported Mack’s car on test that November, when it had to be towed back to town after a malfunction of its steering and it frightened a horse. Mack’s efforts were recognized in South Bend by his listing as an “auto mfr” in the 1905 city directory.

Walter Mack died in March 1906, not having further developed his automobile nor the Taylor wheel. Subsequent to the dispersal of his estate, the car disappeared from view until 1927, when Charles Fieldhouse purchased it at auction. Finding its construction quite remarkable, he decided to build a museum to house it. The Hubbard Hill Museum in Elkart, Indiana opened its doors in 1965, but Fieldhouse died in 1969, and the car was sold in 1971. It was bought by a local collector from Goshen, Indiana, reportedly edging out a buyer from the Harrah Collection. It remained in Indiana until 1999, when it was acquired by the current owner.

Because of the car’s remarkable construction and original condition, it was stabilized rather than restored. Following a general cleaning and lubrication, it started on the third pull, after sleeping for 75 years. It had apparently never been named, so it was titled as “South Bend,” the city where it was built. Today, the car remains in the same unrestored and conserved condition. Its engine is free and runs, but some grooming will be necessary if it is to be commissioned for the road.

Truly outstanding is the accompanying large dossier of information, which includes copies of invoices for parts purchased by Walter Mack, news reports of the car’s operation in 1904, and numerous documents pertaining to the settlement of his estate in 1906; the originals of these documents are held by the St. Joseph County Archive in South Bend, Indiana. Their survival has filled out knowledge of its history, which also confirms its potential eligibility for the famed London-to-Brighton Veteran Car Run in Britain.

Please contact our exclusive automotive transportation partner, Reliable Carriers, for a shipping quote or any other information on the transport of this vehicle.

Alexander Weaver


+1 864 313 6844
California, United States

Alexander Weaver joined RM Sotheby’s in 2011 as a Car Specialist after graduating from Furman University in South Carolina. Born... read more

Augustin Sabatié-Garat


+44 (0) 74 1511 4179
United Kingdom

Augustin Sabatié-Garat joined RM Europe in 2012 as a Car Specialist after more than a decade in the collector car hobby. Gradua... read more

Barney Ruprecht


+1 203 912 7168
Ontario, Canada

Barney’s interest in classic cars began at an early age after being introduced to his father’s all-original 1965 Porsche 911. Barney l... read more

David Swig


+1 415 302 2247
California, United States

David Swig joined RM Sotheby’s West Coast division as a Car Specialist in May 2015. David is a life-long automobile enthusi... read more

Don Rose


+1 617 513 0388
United States

Don joined RM in 2006 after several years of professionally trading sports and classic cars, and after earning a reputation as a noted... read more

Donnie Gould


+1 954 566 2209
Florida, United States

Donnie Gould joined the RM team in 2002 as a partner and Car Specialist after more than two decades in the vintage automobile auction ... read more

Gord Duff


+1 519 352 4575
Ontario, Canada

Gord Duff began his journey with RM Sotheby’s in 1998. Since then, he has gained an intimate knowledge of a variety of marques a... read more

Jake Auerbach


+1 310 559 4575
California, United States

Jake Auerbach got his start in the automotive industry at an early age, spending his summers during high school working at a classic c... read more

Kurt Forry


+1 717 623 1638
California, United States

Having worked for Bonhams’ Automobilia department for over 10 years, Kurt Forry joined RM Sotheby’s with more than a decad... read more

Matt Malamut


+1 805 231 6410
California, United States

A long-time car enthusiast and Southern California native, Matt studied Automotive Technology at San Diego Miramar College and complet... read more

Michael Squire


+44 (0) 20 7851 7070
United Kingdom

Michael Squire joined RM Sotheby’s European Division in the summer of 2016. He comes to RM with a prestigious racing background ... read more

Mike Fairbairn


+1 519 352 4575
Ontario, Canada

As one of the three founding partners of RM Sotheby’s, Mike has a long-standing interest in the classic car industry. Graduating... read more

Oliver Camelin


+44 (0) 75 0110 7447
United Kingdom

With an extensive background in exotic sports car history and sales, a particular passion for American curves, and fluency in three la... read more

Paul Darvill


+44 (0) 20 7851 7070
United Kingdom

Paul Darvill joined the RM Sotheby’s European team at the beginning of 2015. Paul holds a degree in French and Politics from the... read more

Pete Fisher


+1 519 784 9300
Ontario, Canada

Pete Fisher was first introduced to antique cars in high school, working for Classic Coachworks in his hometown of Blenheim, Ontario. ... read more

Shelby Myers


+1 310 559 4575
California, United States

Shelby Myers grew up with the classic car industry infused into every aspect of his life. He had the unique opportunity to watch the R... read more

Tonnie Van der Velden


+31 653 84 19 60
United Kingdom

Tonnie Van der Velden joined RM Sotheby’s European division in September 2015 as a Car Specialist. A lifelong enthusiast, Tonnie... read more